TSLF Employment Blog

black and white rope knotted and pulled against each other

Is Racial Favoritism Legal at Work?

You’re probably already well aware that an employer can’t discriminate against you because of your race. But what happens if the racial discrimination doesn’t take the form of an adverse employment action but instead involves treating another employer better than you because of their race?

The short answer is that such behavior is largely illegal under federal and most state laws. Employment favoritism, or preferential treatment, is not automatically illegal. But if it’s based on someone’s inclusion or exclusion from a protected class (such as race), then it’s almost always going to be illegal.

Overview of Anti-Discrimination Employment Law

There are a host of various federal laws that prohibit discrimination in the workplace based on a protected trait or class. These are certain characteristics of an individual that laws will explicitly protect from discrimination. Some of these include:

Some states have also passed their own laws to provide greater protections against discrimination. For example, in Washington, D.C., the DC Human Rights Act’s (DCHRA) age discrimination protections apply to anyone 18 years of age or older. It’s also illegal for an employer to discriminate against an employee based on the employee’s political affiliation or family caretaking responsibilities.

When discrimination based on these traits occurs in the workplace, it’s usually adverse to the employee. For instance, a boss decides not to promote a female employee because she’s pregnant. Or a hiring manager decides to fire an employee that’s 60 years old to get some “new blood” into the company.

But what happens if, instead of taking adverse action against the employee because of a protected trait, they show favoritism to someone because they possess (or lack) a particular trait? It all depends on what that trait is.

Preferential Treatment in the Workplace

Favoritism and workplace preferences are perfectly legal, as long as they’re based on characteristics not protected by law (like those listed above). So if your colleague gets a larger annual bonus than everyone else because she graduated from the same college as your boss, that’s legal. It might be unfair and a poor business decision, but it’s not against the law.

But that same decision involving the annual bonus that went to your colleague is now being made because she’s a woman? That’s almost always going to be illegal assuming the employer is subject to applicable law. Certain employers, such as those of a certain size, aren’t always subject to anti-discrimination employment laws. As a case in point, the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII) only applies to employers with 15 or more employees.

Summing It Up

Favoritism at work is legal, unless it’s based on an employee’s inclusion or exclusion of a protected group. These are protected classes and are identified by various state and federal anti-discrimination laws.

Share this post

Latest Articles

A Look Back at the Biggest Employment-Related Stories of 2023

A Look Back at the Biggest Employment-Related Stories of 2023

2023 was quite the year in terms of notable events and 2024 is shaping up to be no different. Here are some of the biggest labor-related news stories from last year. Even if you didn’t hear about these events, there’s a good chance you’ll likely feel their effects, even if indirectly. Key Supreme Court Decisions […]

Understanding 5 Key Terms in Virginia Severance Agreements

Understanding 5 Key Terms in Virginia Severance Agreements

Understanding the complexities of Virginia severance agreements is crucial for anyone navigating a job transition. While many believe these agreements primarily benefit the departing employee, they also offer several protections to the employer. They can provide a financial cushion and ease the transition for employees while offering employers insurance against future disputes. However, these agreements […]

What Are My Privacy Rights as an Employee in Virginia?

What Are My Privacy Rights as an Employee in Virginia?

Maintaining the delicate balance between workplace monitoring and employee privacy rights is a critical issue in Virginia. Modern technology has expanded the scope of employer surveillance, making it crucial to understand the legal boundaries. Employees in Virginia should be aware of their rights concerning phone call monitoring, email surveillance, internet usage, video surveillance, and social […]

Everything You Need to Know About Bereavement Leave in Virginia

Everything You Need to Know About Bereavement Leave in Virginia

Coping with the loss of a family member is undeniably one of life’s toughest challenges. During these difficult times, employers can play a crucial role in supporting their staff. Many employers in Virginia extend the provision of bereavement leave to help employees navigate their grief. Unfortunately, such accommodations are not universally mandated by law. If […]

Schedule a Free Case Review

Talk To A Real Person

Play Video

Talk To A Real Person